by Kate Shunney
Three weeks after West Virginia justices heard oral arguments about the status of Vince Shambaugh’s suspension from his role as Morgan County Magistrate, the state’s highest court has ordered that Shambaugh will no longer receive his pay while temporarily suspended from duty.
The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia issued the order on Friday, November 13.
Shambaugh had been suspended with pay for nearly five months — from June 17 until the order took effect on November 13.
The annual salary for West Virginia magistrates is $75,880 as of July 1, 2026, up from $63,250 previously.
The Supreme Court of Appeals temporarily suspended Shambaugh from his duties as an appointed Morgan County Magistrate on June 17 on the recommendation of the Judicial Disciplinary Counsel for engaging in “serious violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct.”
All of the documents pertaining to those violations have been sealed by the court, meaning they are not available to the public to view.
However, on August 24, the Judicial Disciplinary Counsel filed a supplementary report to the court noting that Shambaugh had since been criminally charged in Morgan County with Brandishing a Deadly Weapon in connection with incidents inside the Morgan County Courthouse in May.
According to police reports and attorneys, he is accused of brandishing a handgun inside the Magistrate offices and threatening to kill other members of the courthouse staff over interpersonal matters.
The Counsel in October renewed their initial motion that Shambaugh be suspended without pay.
During a hearing on October 21, Shambaugh’s attorney argued that they would file new documents under seal to justify why he should continue to receive his salary.
The Judicial Disciplinary Counsel argued that the continued attention on Shambaugh’s conduct had compromised the integrity of the judiciary in Morgan County to the extent that his suspension should not include pay.
According to the order filed in the Supreme Court, the decision to impose a suspension without or without pay is based on factors including “whether the charges of misconduct are directly related to the administration of justice or the public’s perception of the administration of justice” in addition to whether the actions of the judicial officer are entirely personal in nature or whether they “related to the judicial officer’s public persona,” whether the court officer is criminal indicted or whether “charges of misconduct involve violence or a callous disregard for our system of justice.”
Under the order, the Judicial Disciplinary Counsel is “directed to file formal charges with the Clerk of this Court when appropriate.”
With the suspension, Shambaugh is prohibited from hearing any judicial cases or performing any judicial functions.
Morgan County is served by two Magistrate judges. Magistrate Greg Miller has been handling the bulk of the Morgan County Magistrate docket, with assistance from magistrates from other Eastern Panhandle counties, during Shambaugh’s suspension.
Morgan County voters had elected Shambaugh in May 2026 to his first full elected term in office but he was suspended from duty before he could be sworn in or begin that term. He was originally appointed as magistrate to fill a vacancy left open on the bench when K.C. Bohrer declined to take office in 2024. Shambaugh is the former Sheriff of Morgan County.
The post Supreme Court pulls Shambaugh pay during suspension from Magistrate bench appeared first on Morgan Messenger.