Questions Continue To Swirl Around MA Investigators’ Handling of Birchmore Case

Posted

A day after Sandra Birchmore, a 23-year-old pregnant woman, was found dead, tied to a doorknob in her bedroom, rumors began to swirl through police circles about a detective she had met when she was a teen recruit in the Stoughton Police Explorer’s Program.

His name was Matthew Farwell. And his colleagues, cops he worked with from the Norfolk County CPAC unit, would soon learn he was the last person to see her alive after surveillance video was located by the property manager of Birchmore’s Canton apartment building of him entering and leaving. Even then, Farwell was not considered a suspect.

No one was, Farwell’s twin brother William testified this month. The lead investigator on Birchmore’s case, Massachusetts State Police Lt. John Fanning, who had gone to high school with the brothers, met with William Farwell in a parking lot after Birchmore’s death, complaining that calls were flooding into investigators that disputed the cops’ determination that she had taken her own life.

“He told me I was not a suspect and that there were no suspects,” William Farwell testified in his twin’s trial.

He also recalled Fanning saying, “I need this like I need a f—ing bullet in the head.”

This week Farwell was found guilty by a federal jury of murdering both Birchmore and the child that he had long believed was his, choking the life out of the woman whom he had begun sexually exploiting when she was a 15-year-old child and he was a 27-year-old detective. The murder was committed; the jury determined to keep her quiet about that abuse.

Ex Stoughton detective Matthew Farwell’s arrival and exit from Sandra Birchmore’s apartment building on Feb. 1, 2021
Credit: Department of Justice

Farwell’s conviction was celebrated by Birchmore’s friends and family, who never believed that she would take her own life and that of her unborn child. But the aftermath has renewed alarming questions about the state’s handling of Birchmore’s death investigation, which began on Feb. 4, 2021, when the young teacher’s aide’s body was found affixed to a doorknob, the other strap wrapped around her neck.

From day one, Birchmore’s boss, an elementary school vice principal, her therapist, her family, and multiple friends had called the Norfolk County District Attorney’s office and the investigators assigned to work cases there, expressing suspicions about Farwell, a married man whose wife gave birth to their third child hours after Birchmore died.

“Michael Morrissey needs to answer for this,” Birchmore’s cousin Barb Wright said. “Those cops, his friends who covered it up need to answer for this. It is a travesty of justice.”

Sandra Birchmore’s cousin Barb Wright calls the death investigation conducted by Norfolk County “a travesty of justice”
Credit: Michele McPhee

Morrissey is the former state representative who was elected as the top prosecutor for Norfolk County, a cluster of towns on the south shore of Massachusetts, in 2010. In recent years, he has been heavily criticized for his handling of the Karen Read prosecution in connection with the death of Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, whose body was found in a snowbank a year after Birchmore died. Read was charged with murder after Morrissey’s investigators said she hit her boyfriend with her SUV after a night of drinking. Her first trial ended in a hung jury; her second in an acquittal on murder charges with jurors calling the Norfolk CPAC unit investigation into her suspicious.

Even federal prosecutors repeatedly expressed concerns about what they called an apparent “cover-up” in the Birchmore case. After Farwell’s conviction, Morrissey released a statement that just increased the scrutiny around his handling of Birchmore’s case.

“The Norfolk District Attorney’s Office (NDAO) recognizes the criticism it has received for its handling of this case,” the statement read. “However, its ability to prosecute was constrained by the finding of the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (OCME) that the manner of death was suicide.”

Michael Morrissey, the outgoing Norfolk County D.A., is being criticized for blame shifting in failure to bring Sandra Birchmore killer to justice
Credit: Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office

Only that statement is not supported by testimony in Farwell’s trial. Dr. María Del Mar Capó-Martínez, the forensic pathologist who made that initial suicide determination, took the stand to say she only ruled Birchmore’s death a suicide based on information she was provided by the state troopers in charge of the case, including Lt. John Fanning.

The troopers never asked her to consider whether Birchmore was killed, Capó-Martínez told the jury. Before she issued a death certificate in May 2021 listing Birchmore’s cause of death as suicide, Capó-Martínez said she checked in again with Fanning.

“Nothing new to report,” Fanning told her in an email. Capó-Martínez changed Birchmore’s death certificate earlier this year to cause of death “asphyxia” with the manner of death now reading “undetermined.” Farwell’s attorneys accused federal officials of pressuring her to make the change, an allegation she denied.

Before joining the state police, Fanning had been a Stoughton Police Officer, like Matthew Farwell and his twin brother William. He had gone to high school with the brothers and still played hockey on the Stoughton Police team. Days after Birchmore was found dead, Fanning told William Farwell that there were “no suspects” in her death because it was only being investigated as a suicide. Fanning was concerned about the flurry of calls coming into Norfolk County pointing at Matthew Farwell and needed to shut the case down.

Fanning had also been reprimanded by his Massachusetts State Police superiors for not properly supervising Trooper Michael Proctor, the lead investigator in the Read case, who was fired after horrifying text messages about his suspect and others were recovered on his phone. In one group text, Proctor called Read a “wackjob c—” that was shared with Fanning.

In a press conference that followed the guilty plea, Massachusetts United States Attorney Leah Foley had praise for Deputy Chief Brian Holmes, who hired private investigators to investigate Birchmore’s death when calls came into the Stoughton Police Department about the Farwell brothers, and another man who was part of Birchmore’s life when she was a child recruit, Robert Devine. That report uncovered horrific abuses that forced the Farwell twins and Devine off the force.

Sandra Birchmore’s cousin Ray Cosgrove; federal prosecutors Elizabeth Riley; Brian Fogerty; Torey Cummings after Matthew Farwell was found guilty
Credit: Michele McPhee

Holmes told Los Angeles he had brought that report to Morrissey and pressed for charges against Matthew Farwell after text messages he exchanged with Birchmore pointed to a statutory rape charge, along with deprivation of rights. Morrissey refused, Holmes said.

As Deputy Chief in Stoughton, Brian Holmes was so alarmed by an internal report on his own cops he called the FBI
Credit: Kingston Police Department

So he went to the FBI. “It’s an unspeakable tragedy,” Holmes said. “She was a sweet kid. She deserved better.”

The case is far from over, multiple sources tell Los Angeles. Morrissey’s fourth term will end in January, and incoming District Attorney Djuna Perkins has promised to seat a grand jury to investigate the Stoughton Police Explorer’s Program. Federal prosecutors have also hinted at possible wire fraud charges for officers who were having sex with Birchmore on duty.

The post Questions Continue To Swirl Around MA Investigators’ Handling of Birchmore Case appeared first on LAmag.

Crime, FBI, John O'Keefe, Karen Read, Massachusetts, Massachusetts State Police, Matthew Farwell, Sandra Birchmore, William Farwell