The Sharks, frankly, are bad at pretty much everything so far this 2026-27 NHL season. So how can the team be better? It starts with the individuals.
At the quarter mark of the season, they’re a mediocre 8-11-2. As of Nov. 13, they’re 29th in the NHL in 5-on-5 goal differential. Simply put, they can’t score and give up too much.
San Jose also has slacked at special teams, after a quick start. San Jose ranks 23rd with a 19.0 power-play percentage and 20th with a 76.0 penalty-kill percentage.
About the only thing that has clicked for the Sharks is their goaltending: Both Yaroslav Askarov and Alex Nedeljkovic have positive goals saved above expected, per Stathletes, meaning analytics believe that they’re stopping more than they should.
So maybe Nedeljkovic is a welcome voice to speak on how San Jose can get better.
“We just need a little bit more out of each guy,” Nedeljkovic said. “Whether that’s putting a stick in the right lane, blocking a shot, winning a 50-50 puck, getting a puck deep, me making a save or Asky.”
So, digging into Stathletes’ microstats, here’s one thing that each Sharks forward realistically can improve at, so the next quarter of the season is better than a disappointing first.
I’ll evaluate the defensemen later, exclusively at San Jose Hockey Now.
“Everybody’s got to just do one more thing,” Nedeljkovic said. “You do that, and then you start getting a little bit more and a little bit more, and then it builds and builds, and then that’s what it takes to win.”
Celebrini owns a 66.6 percent 5-on-5 pass-completion rate, worst among Sharks forwards. In comparison, Alex Wennberg’s 80.3 paces the team up front.
Before the season, Celebrini said puck management was the No. 1 thing that he wanted to improve.
“I turned the puck over a lot last year, and some of that goes into decision-making, being smart with the puck, and not making those high-risk plays all the time,” Celebrini said.
Of course, Celebrini has the puck a lot, so he’s going to turn it over more than the average player.
But other puck-dominant superstars complete a higher rate of passes, so this is something for Celebrini to continue to aspire to: Last year, for example, Connor McDavid completed 77.3 of his 5-on-5 passes, Nikita Kucherov 72.3, and Nathan MacKinnon 73.4. That’s just a handful of passes over a couple games, but that also can be the difference between winning and losing.
Chernyshov’s 5-on-5 rate, 0.47 inner slot carries per 60, is far behind his pace last year. These are puck carries into the most dangerous scoring area of the ice: Wennberg’s 2.46 per 60 tops the Sharks.
Chernyshov actually led the team last year with 2.04 5-on-5 inner slot carries per 60, which is what you want from a winger with his size, skill and skating combination.
Hopefully, Chernyshov attacks the net with aplomb when he returns from injury: San Jose is short on forwards who take the puck to the house.
Dellandrea’s 5-on-5 rate, 4.62 puck deflections per 60, is 11th among Sharks forwards. Ivar Stenberg, surprisingly, tops the team with 11.46 up front, suggesting that the rookie does a good job of getting his stick in passing lanes.
Dellandrea was third among San Jose forwards last year, so this is a defensive category that he has excelled in before. He also is lagging on the penalty kill in puck deflections this season, so a slight improvement there will help the PK.
Forty percent: Goodrow’s 5-on-5 puck battle win percentage is headed south.
In comparison, Celebrini leads Sharks forwards with a 66.0 percent, followed by Dellandrea at 60.0 and Sherwood at 59.7.
Last season, Goodrow won 45.2 percent. In his last two years with the New York Rangers, he won 57.2 percent.
It might be time to sit the 33-year-old winger, here and there, to keep him fresh? Goodrow doesn’t provide offense, so his value comes in the trenches.
Graf’s 4.31 5-on-5 shots per 60 is second-to-last among San Jose forwards, ahead of only playmaker-first Wennberg. Tyler Toffolo leads the team at 7.6.
Graf was middle of the pack on the Sharks last year, which helped him score 21 goals.
But the shooting has dried up this season, along with the goals: He has just two so far.
Marchment’s 5-on-5 per 60 rate, 1.81 inner slot shots, is 11th among Sharks forwards. Will Smith leads San Jose with 3.06.
The Sharks need to get inside more at 5-on-5: They’re dead-last in the NHL with 7.35 inner slot shots per 60. This is one of the biggest reasons why they’ve struggled to score this season.
While the 6-foot-4 Marchment isn’t the net-front monster his size suggests he should be, the winger should be at least average in this category: From 2022 to 2025, he averaged 3.18 inner slot shots per 60, middle of the pack for the Dallas Stars.
Marchment certainly is capable of getting inside more. If he does, coupled with his soft hands, the goals will come.
Misa’s 5-on-5 rate, 8.9 shot attempts per 60, is 10th among San Jose forwards.
The 19-year-old, to reach his potential, has to show more confidence in his shot.
This is part of the reason why it has been a challenge to find Misa’s place on the power play: He seems to prefer the flank on the PP, but he needs to be more of a shot-pass threat to supplant Celebrini, Smith or Stenberg there.
Ostapchuk’s 3.34 penalty kill turnovers forced per 60 is half the rate of last year’s 7.09. Wennberg and Dellandrea force the most PK turnovers among Sharks forwards this season, at 9.91 and 9.22, respectively.
The 23-year-old center hasn’t been able to re-capture his 5-on-5 defensive impact from last year, either.
Sherwood’s 69.0 percent pass-completion rate in all situations, is 11th among Sharks forwards.
It’s a few passes here and there, but that’s one of the reasons why Sherwood doesn’t quite cut it as a bona fide top-six winger, despite speed, a big shot and a wrecking-ball approach to the game.
Smith’s 4.08 5-on-5 puck battles per 60, last on the Sharks, suggest that he isn’t engaging enough physically. There’s a balance, obviously, to this: The smallish Smith should be smart with the puck battles that he gets into.
To compare, Toffoli’s 7.05 puck battles is second-lowest on San Jose, while a Smith comp like Clayton Keller averages 6.61.
Smith showed lots of promise on opening night in battle, but he has gone backwards.
No one is expecting Smith to match Sherwood’s team-leading 16.61 5-on-5 puck battles per 60, but he can be more physical.
Stenberg’s 19.8 passes under pressure per 60 is 10th among Sharks forwards at 5-on-5. That’s not surprising for a just-drafted 19-year-old rookie.
But it is a surprise, compared to Stenberg’s 40.37 power-play passes under pressure per 60, right behind Celebrini (41.84) and Marchment (41.67).
What this suggests is that Stenberg is going to become a monster in this area, as he gets quicker and stronger at 5-on-5. But how much can he get better in-season?
Toffoli’s 0.54 5-on-5 high-danger scoring chances per 60, is far off from his 1.01 mark in 2024-25, and closer to last year’s 0.46.
I think this stat is a good barometer of Toffoli’s goal-scoring health: In 2023-24, the four-time 30-goal scorer had 0.81 5-on-5 high-danger scoring chances per 60, and 0.9 in 2022-23. This stat suggests the 34-year-old winger is not getting to his spots as much as he’s accustomed to.
Toffoli got off to a quick start this season, raising hopes that last year’s drop-off was just a speed bump, but the veteran sniper, who has had to deal with a rotating cast of centers, has just one goal in his last 10 games.
Wennberg has zero power-play rebound shots. Yes, he has missed 10 games this season, but it speaks to the state of the Sharks’ power play that their net-front presence hasn’t got hold of a rebound yet.
Last year, Wennberg led San Jose with 12.
When Wennberg starts pouncing on some rebounds, it’ll be a sign that the San Jose PP is starting to click.