CPS Must Better Track Overtime, Extra Pay After Spending Soared Post-Pandemic: Watchdog

Posted
CPS Must Better Track Overtime, Extra Pay After Spending Soared Post-Pandemic: Watchdog Matt Masterson

Chicago Public Schools’ overtime and extra pay spending skyrocketed following the COVID-19 pandemic, the district’s independent watchdog found, with costs nearly tripling from just before the pandemic up to $150 million in 2024.

CPS Inspector General Philip Wagenknecht’s office (OIG) highlighted “serious concerns” after a 2022 review discovered the cash-strapped school district’s spending on extended day pay, overtime and stipends had jumped substantially, according to a significant activity report published Monday.

The OIG at that time recommended CPS monitor extra pay levels by schools, departments and individuals, and enact cutoffs that would trigger “extra scrutiny” if spending hit certain thresholds, warning that a failure to do so could allow such spending to “rise unchecked.”

“Unfortunately,” Wagenknecht’s office wrote in its report, “the OIG’s prediction came true.”

According to the report, the district’s extra day spending in the 2019 fiscal year — the last full year before COVID-19 hit — was $53 million. That total fell over the next two years, first to $48 million in 2020 and then down to $20 million in 2021, before exploding up to $115 million in 2022 once pandemic restrictions eased.

From there, the report found, spending increased further, to $130 million in 2023 before topping out at $150 million in 2024. Last year, spending decreased to $97 million.

While extra pay spending jumped 83% from fiscal year 2019 to 2025, the school district’s total budget increased only 32%, the report found.

“Unusually large amounts of Extra Pay raise several serious concerns,” Wagenknecht’s office said in its report. “They can lead to reduced productivity, low morale, burnout, high absenteeism, and high turnover. They can reflect favoritism in the assignment of Extra Pay or unrealistic assessment of hiring needs.”

According to the OIG, the report found “exorbitant, potentially questionable” spending, particularly with custodians in the district’s facilities department, who made up nine of the 10 employees with the highest extra pay amounts in 2025.

The report found some CPS employees were paid for overtime amounts that “would appear to be unhealthy” or possibly fraudulent. One custodian punched in and out of work for 77 consecutive days, the report found, while another collected $7,000 in overtime pay after allegedly working 98 additional hours during a regular two-week pay period.

Sixteen CPS employees doubled their salaries in 2025 through extra pay, including one custodian who received $81,000 on top of their regular $61,000 salary, according to the report.

CPS said it is reviewing data on custodial overtime alongside changes in staffing and service delivery and has retrained managers on the overtime process and how to process time.

“Chicago Public Schools takes the Inspector General’s findings seriously and is continuing to strengthen controls over extra pay, including overtime, extended day and stipends," a CPS spokesperson said in a statement. “The District will continue to review and update guidance and monitor payroll procedures.”

According to CPS, custodians were under private management until the end of September 2025, when the district eliminated those private vendors and transitioned to overseeing custodians as CPS employees. 

The district brought all custodial operations under CPS to create what it called a more efficient, reliable and unified workforce.

The OIG’s review found CPS has lacked crucial oversight on excessive extra pay, including no regular monitoring or cutoffs and no protocols for following up with employees with excessive payment amounts.

Wagenknecht’s office made 10 recommendations to CPS about ways to improve its extra pay monitoring. The report states CPS has committed to implementing some of these, including capping the number of extended day pay employees can receive per pay period and modernizing the district’s financial and timekeeping systems.

“With Covid relief funding over, and the district facing difficult budget decisions,” the report states, “controlling and reducing Extra Pay is crucial.”