A Year After A Devastating Fire, The Kelton House Is Moving Toward A New Chapter

Posted

It’s been a little more than a year since a gas explosion and fire severely damaged one of Columbus’ most historically significant homes. But the Kelton House Museum & Garden isn’t giving up on its future. In fact, plans for the property’s next chapter are beginning to take shape, including a proposal to rebuild its damaged rear wing and create a larger event space.

The historic home at 586 E. Town St. has been closed since November 3, 2025, when a natural gas leak led to an explosion and fire that damaged much of the property. The explosion happened in a rear room used for weddings and other events before flames spread through the building and into the attic.

While early reports described the property as a total loss, subsequent assessments offered a more hopeful picture. The historic main house was considered salvageable, and restoration teams were able to recover many of the furnishings, photographs, documents, and artifacts housed inside.

Now, more than a year later, the Junior League of Columbus and The Columbus Foundation are continuing work to preserve the property and determine what its future will look like.

Plans For The Kelton House Include A Rebuilt Event Space

One of the biggest developments came in July 2026, when representatives working on the Kelton House project presented conceptual restoration plans to Columbus’ Historic Resources Commission.

The proposal included rebuilding the damaged rear service wing and creating a larger event space that could accommodate the Junior League’s needs and future museum programming.

The plans aim to restore the property’s historic exterior character while making the rear portion of the building more functional. That includes incorporating salvaged brick and traditional building materials, along with improvements to visitor flow.

During the presentation, the project team indicated that much of the main house’s interior was salvageable, offering another encouraging sign for the preservation effort.

Commissioners expressed support for the general direction of the proposal while raising questions about how new construction would be distinguished from the original historic structure. They also discussed protecting existing trees and considering the project’s impact on the surrounding landscape.

These were conceptual plans, not a final construction approval or reopening announcement. The project still requires additional planning and preservation work.

What’s Happened To The Historic Items Inside?

Saving the building is only part of the restoration effort. The Kelton House also contains a collection of family belongings and historical materials that help tell the story of 19th-century Columbus.

According to the museum’s restoration update, many of those items were saved thanks to the quick response of Columbus firefighters and first responders.

Since the fire, the museum has worked with preservation professionals to assess and care for its collections. Books and other materials affected by the fire have undergone specialized cleaning, while historic portraits and artifacts have been evaluated by experts.

The property also received a new slate roof in December 2025, helping protect the historic structure from further exposure to the elements while restoration work continues.

The collection is particularly important because so much of it is original to the Kelton family. According to the museum, approximately 80% of its furnishings originated with the family, alongside photographs, correspondence, artwork, textiles, china, and other personal belongings.

Preserving those objects means preserving more than a collection of antiques. They’re part of the story of the people who lived in the house and the history that unfolded there.

Brick Italianate exterior with white portico entrance at Kelton House Museum and Garden
via Facebook

Why The Kelton House Matters To Columbus History

Built in 1852 by Fernando Cortez Kelton and his wife, Sophia Stone Kelton, the home has a particularly important connection to Columbus’ Underground Railroad history.

The Keltons were active in the city’s antislavery movement, and family histories identify their property as a place where freedom seekers escaping slavery found refuge.

One of the most significant stories connected to the home is that of Martha and Pearl Hartway, two sisters who escaped slavery in Virginia in 1864.

According to the history preserved by the museum, the sisters eventually arrived at the Kelton property. Martha, who was around 10 years old and too ill to continue traveling, was taken in by the Keltons. Her sister Pearl continued north, eventually reaching Wisconsin.

Martha remained with the Kelton family for years, growing up alongside their children. In 1874, she married Thomas Lawrence in the home’s front parlor.

That history became the foundation for the Kelton House Underground Railroad Learning Station, an educational program that has welcomed thousands of students and adults over the years. Through interactive presentations and historical storytelling, visitors learned about the abolitionist movement and the people who risked their lives to help others find freedom.

It’s a piece of Columbus history that the museum hopes to continue sharing once its doors reopen.

When Will The Kelton House Reopen?

That’s the question without a firm answer just yet.

In its November 2026 restoration update, the museum confirmed that restoration work is ongoing, but regular museum tours and private event rentals remain paused. Select educational programming and community opportunities may continue as circumstances allow.

The organization says it doesn’t want to announce a reopening date before the full scope and timeline of the restoration are known.

The Junior League of Columbus is also marking 50 years of stewardship of the Kelton House in 2026. The organization first took on the task of restoring the property and gardens on July 4, 1976. After three years of work, the museum officially opened to the public in 1979.

Now, five decades after that original restoration, the organization is once again working to preserve the property for future generations.

For now, the Kelton House remains closed, but the work to bring it back is continuing. Those interested in supporting the restoration can contribute through the museum’s official website.

The post A Year After A Devastating Fire, The Kelton House Is Moving Toward A New Chapter appeared first on Columbus Navigator.

News